Richard Davidson is the William James and Vilas Professor of Psychology and Psychiatry at the University of Wisconsin–Madison. A friend and confidante of the Dalai Lama, he is a highly sought after expert and speaker, leading conversations on well-being on international stages such as the World Economic Forum, where he serves on the Global Council on Mental Health. Time Magazine named Davidson one of “The 100 Most Influential People in the World” in 2006.
Davidson is the founder of Healthy Minds Innovations, Inc., an external, affiliated nonprofit dedicated to supporting the mission of the Center for Healthy Minds. He is co-author with Daniel Goleman of "Altered Traits: Science Reveals How Meditation Changes Your Mind, Brain, and Body". He has been featured widely in popular media, including the Today Show, ABC’s Nightline, National Public Radio, National Geographic Magazine, O: the Oprah Magazine, PBS’s The Charlie Rose Show, Harvard Business Review, and additional national and international news outlets.
Thank you for doing Intersections. This has been a blessing during the Covid-19 pandemic.N. Sethi
These sessions give me extra motivation to meditate and to try to get the best out of me and others even in very challenging times. Thank you!Veronica Catarino
Thank you so much for this lovely gift of 'Intersections’.Asha Dutia
In this episode of Intersections, Prof. Hitendra Wadhwa has a conversation with Richard Davidson on the topic “The Power and Practice of Meditation”.
What are the latest scientific discoveries about the power and practice of meditation? Can this ancient discipline be a pathway not just to coping with present-day anxiety, depression, and stress, but also to meaning, purpose, and joy?
The episode “The Power and Practice of Meditation” offers key insights on:
Hello everyone. A warm welcome to all of you from Hitendra. I am so honored and delighted that at today's Intersection, we have in our midst someone who truly represents the ethos of this program. In other words, this aspiration we have to create these intersections, these powerful points of confluence between what otherwise may have been very disparate pursuits and pathways in life and leadership. We have as a guest today, Dr. Richard Davidson. I want to spend just a minute introducing the significance of this opportunity we have with our guest before bringing him into our fold for a conversation.
Dr. Richard Davidson, or as he's popularly known as Richie, is a pioneer in studying the psychology of emotions from the vantage point of the physiology of the brain. He is the founder as well of the Center for Healthy Minds. He is a professor of psychology and psychiatry at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, which has been his platform through which a lot of the science has been done over the last several decades. Time Magazine named Richie as one of the 100 Most Influential People in the world to acknowledge the very pathbreaking way he has pushed the boundaries of science in some really powerful directions. He is also a friend and confidante of a very storied figure, His Holiness the Dalai Lama, who himself has, from the direction of spirituality, really pushed the boundaries to create certain very innovative and collaboration platforms with science.
Richie is the author of two really powerful books that give us a popular science understanding of all this pathbreaking research. One is on the emotional life of the brain, and the other is on the latest findings in meditation with his colleague, Daniel Goleman. In addition, he has also sought to translate science into practical impacts for the world. We are going to be talking today not just about the science, but also about the power of this practice in real life through the Healthy Minds Institute and a few offerings they have from there, including this app that all of you will be delighted to be able to access.
On that note, let me invite you into our midst, Dr. Davidson. It is a pleasure to have you with us. Thank you for joining us.
I'm so happy to be here. Thank you for having me.
I'm very grateful. Thank you so much for joining us for what truly is a conversation about a universal truth, universal idea, the pursuit of wellbeing.
My very first question for you is, how did you get started on this work? One thing really unique about you is that you're not just doing the outer work of a scientist. You're also doing the inner work of a truth seeker. In other words, from everything I know about you, you have pursued the path of mindfulness and meditation in your own life as well. Did that interest come first and then you started to do the science or did the science come first and then you were drawn to doing the inner work?
Well, they really co-emerged. I very much appreciate you asking that question. I had the benefit early on in my career to have met a number of people who had meditation and spiritual practice as an important part of their life. Through their demeanor, they really impressed me. They were warm hearted people. They were the kind of people I wanted to be more around. Their warm heartedness was infectious. I wanted to learn more of what their secret sauce was, so to speak.
At the same time, my scientific career began with a really simple question and that question still is a vibrant one in our work today. The question is, why is it that some people are more vulnerable to life's slings and arrows and others are more resilient? And how can we nurture the qualities in a person to promote optimal flourishing? In the early part of my career, I focused mostly on the adversity side of the equation. But then, when I first met His Holiness the Dalai Lama in 1992, that all changed.
Yeah, it's very interesting. When I was thinking about what to major in college, I had two loves. One was psychology and one was math, and I ended up pursuing maths. I love maths and that was a good path for me. At the same time, the reason that I didn't pursue psychology was like what you were just sharing, which is that at that stage in the evolution of the discipline, there was much less of this richness available that you and other pioneers in the last 20, 30 years, have really built for us, which is so much of a focus on the science of human flourishing in our book, what it takes to be in the more positive side. If today I was making the same call and the same choice, I think I would have pivoted much more towards psychology because of all this fruitful and beautiful work that you're doing.
Well, in the early stage of my career, it was very lonely and difficult in many ways, because there was not a particularly receptive attitude in the academy in psychology and neuroscience in particular toward this kind of work. It was really regarded as fringe, even beyond fringe. So, for many years, my senior colleagues encouraged me to pursue something more mainstream.
Yeah. Where is the field now? Do you feel like it has taken a turn so that it is much more well embraced, or is it still the swim that you're doing upstream?
It has definitely changed significantly. If you look at the rate of scientific publications in meditation, in serious scientific journals, there is an inflection point around 2004 or 2005 and the rate of publication increases quite dramatically. There is now federal funding from the National Institutes of Health for this kind of research. 15 years ago or 20 years ago, there really wasn't. When I first began, it was really extremely lonely. When I first started, there were 3 or 4 scientific papers in the area of meditation. Today, there are thousands. One of the wonderful elements for me is a kind of gratification to see how the field has really matured and become a real field of science, particularly over this last decade.
Yeah, I want to stay on your personal journey for a couple more minutes and then come back and have you share more about this beautiful revolution that you are helping shape in science. There is a quote from you that I read in an ABC News item, which says that, every morning you do a period of meditation and then you scan your calendar for about 2-3 minutes, and then for a few seconds, you then pause to reflect on how you can bring the right stuff to each meeting in order to be really present and most helpful. I found that to be really a powerful idea as a way to get a boost to the start of your day. Can you talk a little bit about that practice and what it has meant for you?
Absolutely. Yes, I did it this morning. I meditate every morning. It is something I've been doing for more than 40 years. Over the last maybe 15 years, I have developed a habit on workdays of taking out my calendar right after I meditate and just very quickly scanning the meetings and activities that I have scheduled for that day. Then I spend a few moments reflecting on the people I will meet, the people I will interact with, and how I could be most helpful, show up in the most beneficial way for each of these encounters. It doesn't take a lot of time. Usually, it's not more than 90 seconds or two minutes. It helps me to really adopt the most beneficial mindset for maximizing the opportunities that we have together each day. So, I've talked about that simple practice and my aspiration is that this could be helpful to others.
Especially at a time like this, when the world is going a little bit topsy turvy, we had one crisis and then we've just been hit upon with yet one more. We had anxiety and depression on the rise and now there is also hurt, dismay and anger in some of the more recent developments. In that context, some of these practices that you have studied, that you have inculcated in yourself, what would be some tools in addition to the one that you so beautifully just shared, which could be of value to our community? I noticed on one of your websites you said that well-being is a skill. In other words, not necessarily just a quality that some people have and others don't. So I'm intrigued about that. Tell us what might be some practical advice that you can offer.
Sure. So happy to do that. Before I get to the practical advice, let me just amplify this conclusion a little bit, that wellbeing is a skill. This is something that is central to both our science as well as a more hacktivist dissemination, if you will. But, we have been led to this conclusion through our science, and that is that well-being consists of some specific more elementary skills or pillars or components. We know from scientific research that each of these components or pillars can be cultivated. It can be strengthened. There are specific brain circuits that are associated with these. We know that those brain circuits exhibit plasticity. They can change in response to experience and can change in response to training. So, we view wellbeing as fundamentally not different than learning to play the violin or learning to engage in a complex sport. It requires practice. This is an insight that really comes from another related understanding in neuroscience. This comes from a related insight in neuroscience that there are two fundamentally different kinds of learning. One we call declarative learning, and another we call procedural learning.
Declarative learning is learning about things we can learn the value of wellbeing. We can learn the value of mindfulness or kindness and understand its utility. But that won't necessarily make us a more mindful or a more kind person. In order to really develop these skills in an embodied way, it requires practice and also requires the second form of learning that we call procedural learning. Procedural learning is skill based. It's embodied. It is acquired through practice. It is instantiated in totally different brain circuits. In order to produce real change, we need both. We need declarative learning and procedural learning. So, that is a little bit of a backdrop.
If you don't mind, before you get into the practical tools, can I just please make one extension of what you just said? This message that you're delivering is so powerful. When you break these skills into small steps and you practice some of them, then over time the brain's plasticity just takes you to a beautiful place. Part of my work is in leadership beyond their focus in life. I find the same idea that you just offered is so critical for us to embrace in developing leadership skills as well, not to see people as natural born leaders or not, and not to see ourselves just as entrapped or empowered by whatever our temperament is, but to recognize that there is the discipline that you brought up that could be used as a way to humbly, at whatever stage of life you are at, in whatever leadership position you are at, take on a goal and really approach it in that disciplined way.
Absolutely. I completely agree and very much see leadership also in the same way. Leadership is something that can be cultivated and there are more underlying or elementary constituents that we can identify that comprise effective leadership. That can actually be cultivated.
One of the things that I often remind people is that when human beings first evolved on this planet, none of us were brushing their teeth. And yet today, I think most people would agree that most people on the planet brush their teeth. This is not part of our genome. This is actually a learned behavior. We do this because we recognize that this is important for our personal physical hygiene. What we are talking about now is something important for our personal mental hygiene. I think most viewers would agree that our minds are even more important than our teeth. My conjecture, which is based on a lot of scientific evidence and also personal experience, that if we spend even as short a time as we do brushing our teeth each day, nourishing our mind in positive ways, this world would be a different place.
That's beautiful. I am going to quote you where you said, "I can envision a day when mental exercise will be as much a part of our daily lives as physical exercise." It is so powerful. So, let's go for it. Let's get some guidance from you on some practical tools, especially at a time so charged and challenged like this we can all embrace.
Well, one of the important elements, particularly in a situation, the likes of which we are all in today in this pandemic and also here in the U.S. with the divisiveness of inequality that has been so rawly exposed. When we reflect on the granularity of our daily lives, there is so much activity that actually is quite positive. People are on the whole, good to one another. The very act of physical distancing, which we are asked to do in this time of the pandemic is beneficial not only for ourselves, but also to minimize the likelihood that we spread the virus. So, it's an act of generosity. When we pause and appreciate all of the individuals whose livelihoods we depend on, people who may deliver things to us, people who are on the front lines, medical providers, all of these individuals who help to make our lives function, particularly at this time.
When we reflect on all of the individuals that require us to put a meal on the table and think about that deeply, we recognize how interdependent we actually are. So, spending a few intentional minutes every day, bringing into our minds and our hearts individuals whose actions are of some benefit to us and expressing our appreciation and even formulating how we might express our thanks to them if we see them in the world. Nurturing that kind of warm heartedness through recognizing appreciation is something that is very accessible and it is so prevalent in our daily lives. But, we tend to ignore it. We pass it by. We have a fleeting thought and we don't savor it.
This is an invitation to spend a few intentional minutes and actually strengthen those qualities because they are so important. They are an elixir, which can really calm our minds and help us, particularly in this time.
Yeah. Very nice. I'm hearing a regular discipline on meditation in your case, intentionality that you create first thing in the morning for the rest of the day, a discipline or putting your mind more on what we can appreciate about the present moment and a sense of gratitude as well for all that others are doing as well. That is so beautiful.
Did you find that as you go over the course of the day in what I'm sure is a stretched, demanding busy career and life, that you find it valuable to create pauses to create moments? I remember the story about Gandhi, for example, that one of the people working very closely with him shared. He said that, "Sometimes, in his busy life, he would finish a meeting and then he would ask me, what is the time? Then I would say something like 10.27. And he would say, when is my next meeting? And he said, at 10.30. Then Gandhi would say, OK, great, I have three minutes. Then he would just become still for those three minutes." That was Gandhi's path. But, have you found any such small, little sintering interventions or something during the day itself to do things that you've studied or practiced?
Yes, absolutely. I think that's so important to sprinkle the day with those kinds of really short periods of practice. For example, every meeting that is an important meeting in our center, we begin with a few minutes of practice. We often call it clearing the lens. It's really about taking a few moments to settle, to calm our minds, to open our hearts, and to be fully present for reengaging with what we are about to do. My experience is that taking these 2 or 3 minutes before important meetings is the return on that investment is multiplicative in terms of the quality and efficiency of the subsequent meeting.
This is one way in which we have baked it into our work routine in our daily work life. Another period during the day where I find this is easy and enormously helpful and it can be done with one's family, too, is around meal time. All of us eat several times a day. This is a great opportunity to reflect on appreciation and all of the people who have been responsible in one way or another for you being able to eat this meal. Spending a few moments before eating in that way can be enormously beneficial.
It is kind of coincidental that you see that because, I've been spending the last couple of months in lockdown in India. As you might be aware from your own travels in India, one has the privilege here at times to have staff who can help cook at times for you at homes and offices. I just remember I had this flash in me yesterday that I am just so incredibly grateful for this beautiful food that is being cooked by this gentleman and I want to give him a hug. I want to give him a hug just to thank him for that very beautiful craft for what he puts on our tables every day. So, it's coincidental to me that you've said that. It's going to spur me on to do exactly that. Thank you for that.
You used some really powerful concepts that people can be intrigued about. where can they read about it? Where can they get a little bit more insight about the capacity to learn and master wellbeing?
the Center for Healthy Minds that I direct has an extensive website with all of our publications freely available. I would encourage you to go to our website. It's the Center for Healthy Minds at the University of Wisconsin-Madison. Also, in terms of practical tools, a number of years ago, I started a nonprofit company called Healthy Minds Innovations. The mission of this nonprofit entity is to take the insights from our science and turn them into tools through which we can cultivate and measure well-being at scale. One of the things that we've done is created this app called the Healthy Minds Program. It is freely available thanks to the generosity of our donors and funders. This encompasses the scientific framework for understanding the plasticity of well-being. It includes four major pillars.
The first we call awareness, which is where mindfulness would be. The second we call connection, which is about qualities that nurture healthy social relationships, qualities like appreciation, gratitude, kindness, compassion. The third pillar is insight. Insight is about self knowledge and specifically knowledge of the narrative about ourselves that we carry and how we can develop a healthier relationship to this narrative. And finally, the fourth pillar is purpose, identifying our true North. Most importantly, how can we align more and more of our everyday behavior within our core sense of purpose?
The app includes scientific information about each of these four pillars. It also includes specific practices through which you can cultivate each of these four pillars of well-being. The app finally includes tools to measure your progress along the path. So you can get information about how these four pillars are present to the extent to which they are strong qualities, the extent to which it may be important to nurture those qualities and you can see how they change over time.
Well, thank you for sharing that. That framework that you mentioned is powerful. Those four parts of that journey. I got sparked about Insights. I think maybe that's the part that relates best to this next question, which is in your own journey, more than doing the science and in pursuing the inner journey for yourself, what has been the most significant change that you have experienced for your own self?
Well, I've been doing this kind of work for quite a long time now. I first met the Dalai Lama in 1992. That was a major pivot point for me because he challenged me in that first meeting and asked why I could not use the tools of modern science, which I was using to study qualities like depression and anxiety and stress. He asked, "Why can't you use those same qualities to study kindness and to study compassion?" That really began a pivot and it was a wake-up call. I think that in terms of for me, the most noticeable sorts of changes over the years is that now, I can say with a completely unequivocally that this is really the purpose of my life. I am on the planet now to do this work. Another thing that has changed is the confidence that I have in the importance of this work. I don't want to sound arrogant about this confidence. It's a quiet kind of confidence. It's a conviction that this is something that the world really needs.
I don't have the answers in terms of telling people how it can be done. I think it's very likely to be different for different kinds of people. I often tell people, "You know what, the best form of meditation that you can possibly do, is the form of meditation that you actually do." There are so many things we don't know. But the one thing that I feel I do know and that I can go to the mat with even the most skeptical scientist is that well-being can actually be nurtured.
There is a lot that we need to learn. But the fact that we can actually promote human flourishing to me is beyond the shadow of a doubt at this point in time. I think most people would agree that the trajectory that the world is on right now is not a particularly healthy one. I think this pandemic is an opportunity to stop doing what we have been doing and recalibrate. I believe that this work now is more important than it has ever been.
Yeah, that's beautiful! I have a follow up question. Where do you see science taking us next? One of the things that I've been intrigued about is that, we think about science in the traditional sense, it is meant to open new vistas and frontiers and human knowledge. This science that we are pursuing today on meditation is actually taking something that has been pursued for thousands of years and illuminating a scientific rigor, the power of a practice that communities who have been pursuing it have known for a long time. So, is the science merely going to be a validator or are you also seeing ways in which the science is providing some practice, some tool or some insight back to those truth seekers who can now benefit from this more scientific advancement of their discipline.
It's a great question. Thank you so much for it. I see multiple streams in science. There is basic science and there also is more translational science, the latter, which is addressing more practical issues. On the basic science side, I think there are many really deeply important questions that are being addressed. For example, what exactly is the relationship between the mind and brain and the body in specific contexts? For example, we know that one of the powerful impacts of certain kinds of meditation is to decrease inflammation in the body. Inflammation plays a major role in many chronic illnesses, including in dementia. So unpacking and really better understanding how these are connected is a major area of scientific inquiry today. There are new methods to begin to look at this. There are going to be some very exciting developments.
On really pushing things, there is the science around the dying process, which I think is going to be really important over the next 10 years. The conventional Western understanding of death as being a binary process, when you stop breathing and the heart stops beating, you're dead. There is more and more evidence to suggest that simple minded notion is just not true. Being able to probe the actual process in a much more granular way of what occurs is going to be extremely revealing and important. Of course, the contemplative traditions have their own beliefs about the dying process and it will be very interesting to juxtapose some of those beliefs with the scientific evidence as it begins to emerge.
Then on the translational side, there are some very practical questions. I'll give you an example. Let's say a person decides that she or he will allocate 15 minutes a day to practice meditation, say they're a beginner and they want to start practicing. Is it better for them to practice in one single 15-minute period? in three, 5-minute periods? in five, 3-minute periods sprinkled throughout the day? That question is not even being asked in the scientific literature. So we do not have an answer to that. My conjecture is, it probably differs for different kinds of people, but that's something that we can empirically study. That may be of great value in helping people to launch a practice.
A related question is, you can practice in a formal meditation, but you can also do more active practices. You can practice while you're engaged in activities of daily living. You can practice while you're walking, while you're commuting, while you're doing physical exercise, while you're cleaning your house, and we don't know to what extent practices while you're engaged in those kinds of activities of daily living produce effects which are comparable to more formal meditation. This is a simple but yet practically very important question that we are going to be able to address through the app as the app is used by more and more people will be able to collect these kinds of data, which will be of great interest and will be helpful to people.
Wonderful. I think this seems like a very promising and in some ways boundless set of possibilities about where science can continue to advance. I was particularly intrigued by the part about the study of the process of dying. I've been in touch recently with Dr. Kenneth Ring and the whole work around near-death experiences. It's a topic of deep interest to me as well. It's a powerful arena through which to understand human consciousness. I'm thrilled to hear that among all of these other very promising directions that you and the community are taking.
I want to be mindful of time. I wanted to ask you to help us through a little guided meditation as a perhaps final gift to us before we go.
There is another powerful question, can you give us an example of how well-being practices can actually help people evolve deeply ingrained beliefs? I thought especially with what is going on in the world right now, there is such a critical need for people to be open to revising and re-visiting some of these ingrained beliefs. If you can have a moment, maybe just to give some insight on that, and then perhaps I can invite you to end this conversation with us through a small meditation.
Yes. With regard to that question, first, I really appreciate being asked that question, since it is so important, particularly for our world today. Looking at our four pillars of well-being, the third pillar, which I describe as insight, is really the most relevant to that question, where we can begin to in a very direct, contemplative way, examine what actually is a belief. How do we hold a belief? When we begin to critically examine that process in our mind, it can really help to decrease the grip, if you will, of an ingrained belief, and we can begin to see it more like other thoughts and have less kind of emotional attachment to it. We can transition from there into a practice, if that's OK.
I'm sure all of you spend a lot of time in front of screens, so let's close our eyes and bring awareness into the present moment in a very intentional way, bring awareness into our bodies. And whenever we do a practice like this, however brief, it's always helpful to remind ourselves at the beginning, why we're doing this and to reflect on the possibility that there may actually be an altruistic motivation. Recognizing that calming our mind and opening our heart is beneficial not only for ourselves, but for all the others that we connect with directly or indirectly.
So let's spend just a few moments reflecting on this possibility and see if you can find this altruistic motivation for engaging in this kind of practice.
Now let's take a few moments to bring awareness into our bodies. Are there areas where there is tension? What sensations may you be experiencing? Here the invitation is not to change anything, not to fix anything, not to adjust anything, but simply to be aware. So, using this extraordinary gift that every human being shares with awareness. Infusing our bodies with awareness.
Now let's transition and bring into our minds in our hearts, one or two other people who have been helpful to us in one way or another, particularly over this last period of the pandemic in this challenging time. It may be someone we live with, a spouse, a member of our family, could be someone who works with us, a close friend, it could even be a pet. Let's bring this being into our mind and our heart and see if we can sense this appreciation emerging. And even reflecting on how we might express our gratitude to this person or being the next time we encounter them. As we end this very short period of practice, one of the other things that we always do when we sit down for a formal practice is before we close, reflecting on how we can bring whatever insight, however small it might be, whatever glimpse from the short period of practice and actually bring it out into our lives to benefit others.
So let's spend a few moments reflecting on how we can take these insights and dedicate them to the benefit of others. Let's open our eyes and as we transition and re-engage, see if you can retain the same quality of presence and awareness as you transition into your next activity.
Thank you so much and I very much appreciate this opportunity and I appreciate all that you are doing to bring these insights to this wonderful group through your work in your institute.
Yeah. Thank you so much Richie. I'm reminded of some words by Mother Teresa. She once said, "You cannot give what you do not have." In your case, you've given us a lot. I know you've given that to us because you have it in you.
We are sending you our best wishes and Godspeed in your journey, in both life and your work. Thank you for all you're doing to bring such a powerful new light into science and into our world. I am very grateful.
Thank you so much. I appreciate it. Thank you for having me.
